Re: Was this too personal to post here?by - ray-390 (Fri Mar 10 2006 15:30:08 )
UPDATED Fri Mar 10 2006 15:30:40
Stunning story. The wonderful part about this board and our family of Brokies is just that, it has become a family. To share something truely personal here is to show respect for, and be respected by people we haven't even met, but who have become so familiar and supportive that we want to give them our inner selves. In another thread I commented on the beautiful diversity we share as a group and how our differences add to a loving community rather than create predjudice. "A blue print for world peace." Given we have the safety net of cyber anonymity, it is easier to pour or hearts into a keyboard, and we may not feel as comfortable revealing our soul in a physical world, but as we come to know each other better, I believe we share an understanding that it is the soul by which we will ulitamtely judged not the limitations of superficial characteristics. This family, with all it's physical differences does not judge nor ridicule. That's why nothing seems too personal, and nothing seems too frightening. I would love to share some cherry cake one day with each and every one of you, but even if I never get that chance, I thankyou for baring your souls.
~ Singles Dances? I thought we were dating! ~/
Re: Was this too personal to post here?by - yaadpyar (Fri Mar 10 2006 15:35:46 )
Thanks for the support, ray. You articulated my own thoughts beautifully.
"We could not talk or talk forever."
OT - What/'who' made you non-homophobic (homophile)? by - Ellemeno (Fri Mar 10 2006 15:43:46 )
UPDATED Fri Mar 10 2006 15:47:06
Laura, my near-3 year old also talks about my movie and about Ennis and Jack. "Are they sad?" is something she has asked several times, looking at the dozy embrace pictures. respectful of each other's opinions, glad to have a companion where none had been expected
OT - What/'who' made you non-homophobic (homophile)? by - Ellemeno (Fri Mar 10 2006 16:12:34 )
UPDATED Sat Mar 11 2006 01:43:47
I don't know - my whole life, since being tiny, the concept of fairness has always been hugely important to me. Also the concept of diversity, though that word for it is relatively new. What's that quote about "there is more something something Horatio, than something something dream of?" (Does anybody know the quote I mean?) UPDATE Our lovely hostess on this thread, wang_jude, found the quote! "There are more things in heaven and earth, Horatio, Than are dreamt of in your philosophy." -- From Hamlet (I, v, 166-167) (I couldn't remember the quote, but I knew it applied.)
Having been born in 1959 and growing up in Manhattan, the women's movement in the 70s shaped my sense of self hugely (thank God et al). And the slogan "We are everywhere" made a deep, positive impression on me.
I don't ever seem to want to answer questionnaire-type questions about my sexual orientation, because the box I would check doesn't exist on any questionnaire I've ever seen. None of the typical descriptions tell my whole story. Ever since my early twenties, it seems like about half my women friends are lesbians.
But honestly, I have had some of my (not homophobia, but rather) homo-ignorance dissolved on these two boards, mostly by listening to flashframe77 and spookyrabbitindayard, both of whom I love.
I've just spent about 20 minutes typing, deleting, reinstating, rearranging these words, and I am quite unsatisfied with what I have managed to verbalize. I want to just delete it because it's so incomplete, not tied up in a closure bow. But here I go, pressing Post Reply.
respectful of each other's opinions, glad to have a companion where none had been expected
OT - What/'who' made you non-homophobic (homophile)? by - yaadpyar (Fri Mar 10 2006 16:21:39 )
Elle - Thanks (can't begin to help with the quote). All the thoughtfullness behind it is apparent; glad you hit the post button.
"We could not talk or talk forever."
OT - What/'who' made you non-homophobic (homophile)? by - valerie_lp (Fri Mar 10 2006 17:25:15 )
UPDATED Fri Mar 10 2006 18:53:42
Like delalluvia, I thought the silence from my parents implied consent. (Quitaque consentire!) When I was in high school, the bestseller among us girls was The Secret Diary of Laura Palmer, and there was a scene where she had sex with a woman. I thought it was hot. Every single one of my girlfriends thought it was disgusting, and said so loudly, so therefore I (I was 15, please remember) pretended I did too.
I liked boys a lot, so I wasn't worried I was gay, but always thought maybe one out of 100 girls in my high school was sexy too (as opposed to one out of every 10 boys). Then I went to a VERY liberal liberal-arts college, where my roommate was a lesbian. And going straight into grad school/higher ed in departments with enormous queer studies departments made it seem 100% normal to me.
And my parents have no idea when I got so "liberal." If they only knew.
OT - What/'who' made you non-homophobic (homophile)? by - wang_jude (Fri Mar 10 2006 19:37:08 )
Wow! Very interesting replies. I wasn't even sure whether to ask this question or not, but now I'm happy I did!
****
Amh625, you say you had very liberal parents and upbringing. What was their reason to put you in a Catholic school? Not that it_s wrong, of course, but I find the combination interesting [I_m probably being offensive, asking this.. sorry, but I don_t know how to phrase it better].
****
purplemonkey131 - When I was growing up, I always felt very disconnected from the world. I was never able to get very close to people and I think that's why I wasn't able to easily be brainwashed by society's "values".
****
That so totally makes sense to me!
****
ray-390 - In another thread I commented on the beautiful diversity we share as a group and how our differences add to a loving community rather than create predjudice.
****
Exactly, Ray! If we were all the same, this world would be so boring and bland! I_m not saying it_s easy every day, but it_s a challenge and so damn fascinating!
****
Ellemeno - my whole life, since being tiny, the concept of fairness has
always been hugely important to me. Also the concept of diversity
****
This totally rings a bell! I probably wasn_t fair all the time, with everyone and I_m still not. But I_m trying. In any way, I always gear towards the underdog..
"..it would be a sweet life.." - [J. Twist - BBM]
OT - What/'who' made you non-homophobic (homophile)? by - henrypie (Fri Mar 10 2006 19:47:31 )
Clarissa,
Has the Horatio quote anything to do with Hamlet?
Celeste (and everyone),
Thanks for sharing. I love this thread.
OT - What/'who' made you non-homophobic (homophile)? by - wang_jude (Fri Mar 10 2006 20:09:19 )
A bit more of my number 3: -
****
Yaadpyar - I don't know what to say. I knew my intersts in many, many things were different than the people around me since I can remember
****
That_s sort of true for me too (although probably on a entirely different level than yours). I remember back in Kindergarten there was this kid that _ I believe _ was mentally challenged (nobody had told us anything). He would have a tiny toy and in recess he would put it on the floor and jump around it and make very weird noises. Fascinated by it, I watched this child for ages. Not quite sure why [now, thinking about it, I assume this child was autistic _ hence maybe, my odd attraction to Autism]. When I was older (10-13) in my neighbourhood there was this adolescent girl that had a physical and mental handicap. We had her play with us all the time and she would participate in all the games as much as she could. I remember her still today, but none of the other kids. And the list goes on.. In school when everybody would have their ears pierced, started smoking or followed the latest fashion, I would do exactly the opposite. Not that I was trying to be brighter or more intelligent, but I kind of nurtured the fact of thinking/acting different compared to other children. We were a very small bunch of _outsiders_ but I made sure that the _trendy_ kids would have no reason to bully me and they never did. I liked them and got along with everyone, but I was on a different track somehow.
I have been thriving on differences for as long as I can remember. Odd fascination. Maybe it_s because I had parents from two different countries (two different languages) and was born in yet another. Having been from a very early age, the only one(!) in Kindergarten/school with divorced parents. Yes, it_s true. It changed a bit later on. My mother was frantic that kids in school would bully me for being different. I did not care being a divorcee child! Nor did it had any effect on other kids! (I still believe today, that my parents divorcing so quickly, was the best thing they could have done). My mother having grown up in _faithless_ Communist Germany, would insist on me following Protestant classes (one out of the two compulsory religion classes - the other being Catholic), because she worried I would be too different (again) from my classmates, who were all in one of these courses (except for those very few who had the permission from their parents to follow _morale_ class). She would also dwell on the fact that one important part of education was to travel, but not only for fun purposes, but also to learn things. I guess, all this opened my mind a bit.
Like I said earlier, I have always been interested in _the other_. For some reason (known to me) I have very early on been hmm.. let_s say captivated by gay people. I remember being 14, in Egypt on a Nile cruise and one of the guides being very obviously gay (I guess I have a working gaydar) _ I was infatuated with him and he sensed it, but it was no use, obviously (me being a straight woman). Anyway, around the same time I stayed up late without permission, when home alone, to watch movies by Luchino Visconti, which fascinated me (practically all of them being gay-themed). Had I asked any other girl from my class about Visconti or the content of his films, they would have looked at me in bewilderment, I_m sure, not knowing what I was on about! In school we were reading "Felix Krull" (by Thomas Mann) and to me it was very obvious that the main character (Felix Krull) was attracted to and attracting people from both sexes. When the teacher asked something to that effect and I answered that yes it was so, the rest of my classmates were loudly disagreeing..
I did not feel strange about this. Had any classmate or same-aged friend challenged me on this, I would have ignored them or let them make fun of me. What_s weird, is that my parents are both a bit homophobic and a bit racist_ It probably comes with their age and the historical part of things, but they are not very consistent. Especially my father. I mean, both my parents left their respective countries and never moved back there (and never will). So they are both _foreigners_ where they live now and still they manage to have arguments/comments which are not entirely _politically correct_ towards other foreigners. Weirder even, my father is now re-married with a Muslim woman from Northern Africa (which is cool, because she helps me with my Arabic sometimes, which I_m trying to learn), but I remember times, when he had nothing good to say about other foreigners in a country that isn_t even his own.
On the BBM board in January I posted the following (it_s truncated):
****
[..] As tolerant as I believe myself to be, I know it's constant work to actually remain true to my 'beliefs'. But, and without oversimplifying it, I think that anything is acceptable as long as everyone involved is consenting and nobody gets hurt _ be it physically, mentally or morally!
[..] As long as there is honesty and less/no hypocrisy _ [..] _ and everyone is willing to open up, be flexible about things or people that are 'different' and willing to _ [..] - teach/promote/spread/enable tolerance, love and understanding, then I think this earth could enjoy itself much more and unite in its diversity.
****
Oh no! Now I must stop! I_m rambling! Sorry for syntax errors and crap writing _ I_m no good at it during normal hours, but it_s definitely worse at 5am!
Thanks everyone and good night!
"..it would be a sweet life.." - [J. Twist - BBM]
OT - What/'who' made you non-homophobic (homophile)? by - wang_jude (Fri Mar 10 2006 20:18:47 )
UPDATED Fri Mar 10 2006 20:23:44
****
Yes, it's Hamlet. I Googled -
"There are more things in heaven and earth, Horatio, Than are dreamt of in your philosophy." -- From Hamlet (I, v, 166-167)
Hamlet speaks these lines to his friend Horatio. The sentries who keep night watch over the castle at Elsinore have seen an apparition of the ghost of the late king of Denmark, Hamlet's father. Although Horatio pleads with the ghost to speak to them, it refuses and disappears at morning light. Horatio tells Hamlet about it the next night, believing that the ghost will only speak with his son. Hamlet goes off with the ghost, where he learns that his father was murdered by his own brother, Claudius, who has now taken the crown for himself. When Hamlet returns to Horatio, who expresses his bewilderment over the apparition, Hamlet points out that ghosts speaking, and brothers murdering, and wives remarrying may exist outside the moral framework of the average man... but that these things occur in the real world.
http://www.enotes.com/shakespeare-quotes/275 "..it would be a sweet life.." - [J. Twist - BBM]
OT - What/'who' made you non-homophobic (homophile)? by - yaadpyar (Fri Mar 10 2006 20:31:15 )
w-jude - thanks for getting this started. Can't wait to read the next one. Nice work also on the colors for "Googled." You've set a new standard for marking-up text.
"We could not talk or talk forever."
OT - What/'who' made you non-homophobic (homophile)? by - Ellemeno (Sat Mar 11 2006 01:45:57 )
>> Has the Horatio quote anything to do with Hamlet?
Yes, thanks, henrypie, and wang_jude found it!
respectful of each other's opinions, glad to have a companion where none had been expected
OT - What/'who' made you non-homophobic (homophile)? by - Ellemeno (Sat Mar 11 2006 01:47:53 )
Wow, that feels like the nicest gift! Thank you so much. Group hug!
(In real life I actually loathe group hugs, but here, what the hey!)
respectful of each other's opinions, glad to have a companion where none had been expected
OT - What/'who' made you non-homophobic (homophile)? by - vkm91941 (Sat Mar 11 2006 02:30:20 )
Well...my immediate family, Mom, Dad and 4 Brothers have always been very liberal and open minded. We were all raised to believe that there were 2 commandments, Love GOD and Love your neighbor as yourself. That meant everyone. We were as good as anyone and better than no one. If you did this everything else would fall into place. My cousin is gay he lives in the Silverlake district in Los Angeles and all my life he has spent his holidays with us and always felt free to bring his friends along. When I went to college, my first year I meet a woman who pursued me, I experimented some with her and came to the realization that women didn't do it for me...My second year I meet a wonderful man, who is still my friend to this day and is god father to my youngest. He's gay and is the person who introduced me to gay fiction when he gave me The Front Runner to read. So I guess it just never occured to me that I should feel any other way. I mean sexuality is such a small part of our identity as people it really should not matter.
Victoria M
Forget about what you thought you were and just accept who you are
OT - What/'who' made you non-homophobic (homophile)? by - promethius99 (Sat Mar 11 2006 07:18:23 )
I want to say that getting mad with homophobics is not helping with anything, ignorance is the underlying evil, always take the high road....one day society will change.
OT - What/'who' made you non-homophobic (homophile)? by - vkm91941 (Sat Mar 11 2006 10:10:27 )
That is something I pray for everyday.
Victoria M
Forget about what you thought you were and just accept who you are
OT - What/'who' made you non-homophobic (homophile)? by - BannerHill (Sat Mar 11 2006 10:52:13 )
I grew up in a Quaker, knee jerk liberal home environment. My parents were active members of the Civil Rights movement.
My mother was a charming story teller and the sort of person people gravitated to, in an 'Aunti Mame' sort of way. Our home was frequently resembled an intellectual salon. Gay men and women were frequent visitors.
Not surprisingly, I ended up somewhat less liberal.
"Hey Ennis, do you know someone named 'Jack'?"
OT - What/'who' made you non-homophobic (homophile)? by - spottedreptile (Sat Mar 11 2006 12:06:48 )
Does anyone remember the book Twins (it came out as a movie called Dead Ringers) - well I bought this when I was an early teen, I saw it in the bookshop and the title kind of appealed to me. I didn't read it when I got home but my mum did. Later she came up to me and said "I hope you don't go and do anything like these two dreadful men did. Homosexuality is dirty and a sin."
Well, of course I read the book immediately! Plus I was at that age when you can't stand anything your mum says or does, so it stirred up my rebellious spirit and from then on I got quite interested in why it was so 'sinful' - and found out about gays the way most kids do - talked about it at school etc.
But I've always had an interest in slash, ever since I was about 8, when I watched The Man from Uncle, which is weird, but there you go.
My sister is in a gay relationship now and I find some of her stories about prejudice, even in the 21st century, a bit eye-opening. It's never occurred to me to see homosexuality as anything sinful, it's always seemed to be just another form of love, and for the life of me I can't understand to this day why people get so upset about it, apart from what others have drummed into their heads. Oh well.
OT - What/'who' made you non-homophobic (homophile)? by - promethius99 (Sat Mar 11 2006 12:36:41 )
I don'teven think about it tbh, live and let live eat drink and be merry lets get ice cream
OT - What/'who' made you non-homophobic (homophile)? by - kelda_shelton (Sat Mar 11 2006 14:43:52 )
It's interesting reading all these posts and I'm not really sure how I ended up so 'liberal' - I guess it was the norm and I've never thought so much of it.
My Mum isn't an activist or anything of the sort. And she never came out and said to me at a young age - being homophobic or racist is wrong Kelda, but I guess she instilled in me in some way that its not fair to make judgements on the way people lead their life.
She was a single parent and a working class one at that. I was a clever little one at school and I guess I wanted to make my Mum proud of me so I was a liberal little soul too - although I think that was involuntary really - it just sorta happened. I've always been the sort to stick up for myself and make my views heard - ie My Mummy is a great Mummy and it doesn't matter that I don't have a Daddy cos she's good enough to be both. I was kinda an odd-bod child. Pretty clever and articualte child but from an obviously poorer background than the other clever kids in my class, and I guess I was a tough wee thing to 'make up' for that.
Interestingly, my Mum's best friend from school (I call her my aunty), who she still keeps in good conatact with to this day, has lived in Canada since they were like 25 and for a good 20 years she has been living with a woman.
But she has never actually announced to my Mum that she is gay. I'm making a presumption here I suppose, because maybe - just maybe - she isn't gay. I mean - my Mum has never been able to afford to make it out to Canada so she can't see their living arrangements, but the holiday together, my aunt is the woman's carer when she has been ill, they send and recieve emails/christmas cards/birthday cards as xx & xx. And I asked my Mum recently, have you never asked aunty if she is gay, in all this time? And my Mum just said, I've never really thought about asking her outright, and I can hardly ask her now after all these years can I!?
sorry, I blabbered on much more than I intended to!!
BBM-aholic! See..www.revelationtees.spreadshirt.com (& .net!)
OT - What/'who' made you non-homophobic (homophile)? by - wang_jude (Sat Mar 11 2006 18:31:15 )
****
My Mum isn't an activist or anything of the sort. And she never came out and said to me at a young age - being homophobic or racist is wrong Kelda, but I guess she instilled in me in some way that its not fair to make judgements on the way people lead their life.
****
Kind of the same here. It was implied in certain things she did or said (or didn't say), I guess. Although, I wrote in an earlier thread that both my parents are a bit homophobic and a bit racist and I know I would never be able to have a lasting discussion on gay/lesbian marriages or adoption with my father, because it would very possibly end in a fierce argument. But my mother (75 years old - she had me late ) did, for example, sublet her attic to a gay man for a while once and come to think of it, I never ever heard her say anything nasty (..I use this word a lot now for some reason..) about homosexuality. I've never prompted her on the issue, but I think the 'topic' isn't even 'worth discussing' if I may say so. She has been through enough stuff in her life (WWII, father deported, Communism [my mother is from former Eastern-Germany], divorce [never bad-mouthing my father for cheating and leaving her], single parent to two kids) and I just feel that the 'gay issue' isn't actually an issue for her.
In the same way did she 'inadvertently' teach me openness, I guess. Without really discussing homophobia/racism much openly, I understood that it wasn't anything to get mad/sad at. Being German, having experienced WWII first-hand, telling me how her Jewish class-mates suddenly 'disappeared', taking me to a concentration camp, having a long-lasting Jewish friend (who went through hell), having lived with an old Jewish painter-lady for a while, before getting her own place etc. - no wonder when I told my mother about 13/14 years ago that I'd love to go to Israel on holiday, she did not surprise me, when she said she always wanted to go too! And we did! I've been to Israel 3 more times since and like New York, it is a place where I'd go back again and again!
So, now, I actually just converted my mother into a very liberal person (well, with limitations, but they are understandable), albeit not a very obvious/talkative one! Maybe she is a closeted Lesbian. What?! Wait! Did I just write this?! Hmm.. I'm trying to think of some clues.. Married late, really only wanted one child (my sister), but my father insisted, wanted a boy, getting me instead.., divorcing my father, never in another relationship except one very short one.. Hmm..
I'm a bit embarrassed.. You know my whole story now.. I might delete some of that stuff later..
"..it would be a sweet life.." - [J. Twist - BBM]
OT - What/'who' made you non-homophobic (homophile)? by - wang_jude (Sat Mar 11 2006 18:45:37 )
****
w-jude - thanks for getting this started. Can't wait to read the next one. Nice work also on the colors for "Googled." You've set a new standard for marking-up text.
****
>> Has the Horatio quote anything to do with Hamlet?
Yes, thanks, henrypie, and wang_jude found it!
UPDATE Our lovely hostess on this thread, wang_jude, found the quote! "There are more things in heaven and earth, Horatio, Than are dreamt of in your philosophy." -- From Hamlet (I, v, 166-167) (I couldn't remember the quote, but I knew it applied.)
****
Ooops! Did not see these! Thank you Celeste and Clarissa (hey, this sounds like you could be in some ethereal group together)!
Please call me Jude
"..it would be a sweet life.." - [J. Twist - BBM]