Brokeback Mountain: Our Community's Common Bond > Brokeback Mountain Open Forum
The mysterious "I love you" and other nearly indiscernible moments
Brown Eyes:
--- Quote from: Front-Ranger on July 07, 2006, 05:28:44 pm ---That special edition is supposed to come out this month!!
--- End quote ---
Really! Where did you hear this? Oooo, see now, you're getting us all excited!
:D ;D
OK, I have a question about another "nearly indiscernible moment"... much less exciting than the shirts or TS1. So, when Jack is pacing around in Lureen's office looking for his blue parka... Lureen says "you're the only **blah, blah, blah** salesman in fact..." What does she say here?? I hate watching the movie with subtitles (they just irritate me for some reason) so I've never gotten around to checking this scene out with subtitles. I'd surely appreciate it if someone has some insight here.
thanks!
serious crayons:
I think it's, "You're the best combine salesman we got -- you're the only combine salesman, in fact."
You probably know this, but a combine is a piece of farm equipment. I mean big farm equipment. It's among the $100,000 shit.
I believe what it does is harvest grain.
dly64:
--- Quote from: latjoreme on July 06, 2006, 04:05:12 pm ---OK, then, here's my advice. Right after he breathes in the shirts, hoping for the scent, his face up close to the cloth -- watch for the left 1/4 inch or so of his mouth to twitch three times, as if he's saying three one-syllable words. Listen for him to make three short sounds, ditto. It won't sound or look particularly like "I love you." He could be saying just about anything, or twitching for some other reason. But that's the reason that makes the most sense -- and is the most emotionally thrilling -- to me.
Then, immediately -- and I mean IMMEDIATELY -- afterward, it cuts to Mrs. Twist in the kitchen. So if you get there and haven't seen it, rewind slightly and try again.
Good luck! Report back tomorrow!
--- End quote ---
Katherine – Okay, girl. I never thought I’d say this …. (I can admit when I am wrong, however) …. I heard the “I love you …” I can’t believe it. I honestly have to say that I thought it was absurd to think that Ennis would say "I love you" while holding the shirt. But I followed what you said and you are correct. It is extremely subtle. You are right that it does not take anything away from the story.
So what have I learned from being a participant on BetterMost? Nothing is a given. My opinions that I was so sure about are now wavering. I have come to a decision … when I watch my nightly viewing; I am going to watch it as if I have no preconceived ideas/ notions. It won’t be easy to do. I do think, however, I may see things in a different light. So, we’ll see …. I guess you can teach dogs new tricks! ;)
serious crayons:
Welcome to the club, Diane! :D :D :D Glad to have your agreement, both on its existence and that it's not damaging to the story. And I'm like you -- I never thought it could possibly be there, until I saw it.
You're right, I think you can keep going and going and finding out more and more things -- about the movie and about ourselves. I like your idea of trying to watch with no preconceptions. :o :)
dly64:
--- Quote from: latjoreme on July 08, 2006, 07:22:45 pm ---Welcome to the club, Diane! :D :D :D Glad to have your agreement, both on its existence and that it's not damaging to the story. And I'm like you -- I never thought it could possibly be there, until I saw it.
You're right, I think you can keep going and going and finding out more and more things -- about the movie and about ourselves. I like your idea of trying to watch with no preconceptions. :o :)
--- End quote ---
I'll let you know if I see something else ... who knows?
Navigation
[0] Message Index
[#] Next page
[*] Previous page
Go to full version