The World Beyond BetterMost > Anything Goes
Share your energy/resource saving tips
Giancarlo:
--- Quote from: starboardlight on July 23, 2006, 08:29:04 pm ---actually a rudimentary understand of supply/demand might lead you to think that that's always true, but you're arguing with an econ major here. the laws of supply and demand is not always an upward curve. Economy of scale is a factor that can shift the supply curve to the right and thus puts a downward pressure on price. The overhead cost of running a power plant is always constant, and is distributed into each unit of consumption. If the power plant produce twice the amount of energy, the overhead/unit cost will be half as expensive. In which case, an increase in demand would in fact result in a lower per unit cost.
--- End quote ---
I may not be an econ major, but my major (political science) deeply requires economics, and I did take several courses involving that (I am taking a course called business ethics this upcoming semester but it is more for my general education requirements). I never said supply and demand is an upward curve. But when it comes to power, the more that is demanded the higher prices go up, and we in California know that dearly. By the way, if you put a lot of strain on a power plant by demanding that it produces more power you run the risk of a fire or even a plant meltdown. What happened in Santa Monica yesturday was a much smaller scale outage but it equals a electrical meltdown. Myspace for example was knocked out because of that outage. The circuits overloaded and there was a fire. You need to take into account natural forces, which no offense or anything, they don't seem to teach you in economics. You cannot just demand that a power plant produces twice the amount of energy. You actually have to upgrade or expand it.
--- Quote ---Tesla will help its buyers set up a solar charging station at home, so no use of petroleum derived energy to drive the car, so in that sense, it beats the hybrid.
--- End quote ---
Impractical and expensive. It doesn't beat hybrid.
--- Quote ---as far as the hybrid being faster. who cares, the Tesla Roadster can go 0-60 in 4 seconds, and has a top speed of 130, which is more than any one needs. What's the stats for speed on the Prius anyway?
--- End quote ---
I highly doubt that is true. The Prius is just a better vehicle and is more cost efficient. The prices are going down for hybrids much faster then they are for electric vehicles, and lets face it... people work in the petroleum market too and it would be disasterous for them if we make a switch to electric. I just think about long term implications.
--- Quote ---without an internal combustion engine, electric cars are cleaner and requires less maintenance. I'm not making this up. Previous owners of the EV will tell you as much.
--- End quote ---
You are making this up in my mind. Hybrids are very effective and can be reversed engineered to go faster, and run longer then electric vehicles.
starboardlight:
--- Quote from: Giancarlo on July 23, 2006, 08:37:45 pm ---I may not be an econ major, but my major (political science) deeply requires economics, and I did take several courses involving that (I am taking a course called business ethics this upcoming semester but it is more for my general education requirements). I never said supply and demand is an upward curve. But when it comes to power, the more that is demanded the higher prices go up, and we in California know that dearly. By the way, if you put a lot of strain on a power plant by demanding that it produces more power you run the risk of a fire or even a plant meltdown. What happened in Santa Monica yesturday was a much smaller scale outage but it equals a electrical meltdown. Myspace for example was knocked out because of that outage. The circuits overloaded and there was a fire. You need to take into account natural forces, which no offense or anything, they don't seem to teach you in economics. You cannot just demand that a power plant produces twice the amount of energy. You actually have to upgrade or expand it.
--- End quote ---
you'd have to upgrade if the plant is already function at capacity. Most plants aren't. Many petroleum currently keep many of their generators off and overtax the ones that are in use. That's what happened in the east coast black out several years ago, and that's what happened in Santa Monica. This is documented in many newspaper reports. But I was talking about green energy. Natural gas plants as well as solar and wind plants which still have room for increased capacity. With these plants, demand increase will indeed bring down the per unit cost for quite a while until we hit critical mass, but that's a long way off.
[quoteI highly doubt that is true. The Prius is just a better vehicle and is more cost efficient. The prices are going down for hybrids much faster then they are for electric vehicles, and lets face it... people work in the petroleum market too and it would be disasterous for them if we make a switch to electric. I just think about long term implications.[/quote]
the numbers are what they are. doubt all you want. but when these cars hit the road next year, we'll know for sure.
--- Quote ---You are making this up in my mind. Hybrids are very effective and can be reversed engineered to go faster, and run longer then electric vehicles.
--- End quote ---
so you're calling me a liar. great. but research into internal combustion engine and electric engine before you actually make such a serious accusation. The electric engine will run cooler because it doesn't generate heat while converting gas to energy. As such, it is less prone to wear and tear. In addition, it can generate more speed precisely because with less heat, there's less friction and thus less strain on the engine.
and we can keep arguing, but this car is hitting Californian road in early 2007, so we'll see the stats and compare. In any case, it's a very viable option, that may not be for everyone, but it's an option in any case. and more option for consumers is a good thing.
starboardlight:
--- Quote from: Giancarlo on July 23, 2006, 08:37:45 pm ---people work in the petroleum market too and it would be disasterous for them if we make a switch to electric. I just think about long term implications.
--- End quote ---
ok, now you're being argumentative just to argue. dependency on petroleum is bad, but wait we need to protect those workers in the petroleum industy. that's an argument that doesn't wash. when a technology or a product become outdated, it's time for those who work in those sectors to retain and get new jobs. They'll be more jobs in green energy as demand increase. More green energy plant will be built to replace dirty petroleum plants. Those people will transition over. That's how technology and society progress. It makes no sense to not switch to electricity just to keep the oil industry at their comfortable jobs. Long term implications, indeed.
Giancarlo:
--- Quote from: starboardlight on July 23, 2006, 09:05:39 pm ---you'd have to upgrade if the plant is already function at capacity. Most plants aren't. Many petroleum currently keep many of their generators off and overtax the ones that are in use. That's what happened in the east coast black out several years ago, and that's what happened in Santa Monica. This is documented in many newspaper reports. But I was talking about green energy. Natural gas plants as well as solar and wind plants which still have room for increased capacity. With these plants, demand increase will indeed bring down the per unit cost for quite a while until we hit critical mass, but that's a long way off.
--- End quote ---
Say what? Now you're running around in circles not really understanding what you are saying. I took into account that you need to make these upgrades.
You know what, I'm not going to argue with anymore. You talk down to me and try to make me feel like an idiot. You pull out "well I'm an economics major" card. I didn't resort to my education as a way to establish "moral and argumentative" superiority over another. We need to improve and build more nuclear power plants.
--- Quote --- so you're calling me a liar. great. but research into internal combustion engine and electric engine before you actually make such a serious accusation. The electric engine will run cooler because it doesn't generate heat while converting gas to energy. As such, it is less prone to wear and tear. In addition, it can generate more speed precisely because with less heat, there's less friction and thus less strain on the engine.
--- End quote ---
A hybrid engine would last longer because it is built differently (it is not necessarily a combustion engine).
--- Quote ---
and we can keep arguing, but this car is hitting Californian road in early 2007, so we'll see the stats and compare. In any case, it's a very viable option, that may not be for everyone, but it's an option in any case. and more option for consumers is a good thing.
--- End quote ---
The Prius is better and is more effective and viable, let alone practical.
--- Quote ---ok, now you're being argumentative just to argue. dependency on petroleum is bad, but wait we need to protect those workers in the petroleum industy. that's an argument that doesn't wash. when a technology or a product become outdated, it's time for those who work in those sectors to retain and get new jobs. They'll be more jobs in green energy as demand increase. More green energy plant will be built to replace dirty petroleum plants. Those people will transition over. That's how technology and society progress. It makes no sense to not switch to electricity just to keep the oil industry at their comfortable jobs. Long term implications, indeed.
--- End quote ---
I never said that we need protectionism on the petroleum industry. We just need to move gradually, because a demanded sided shock could be disasterous for numerous countries that are in OPEC. It is a gradual process. You're thinking quite simplistically too. I didn't say that technology should advance. Do you even know any of my beliefs? Or are you just going to continue talking down to me like I'm illiterate or a child? I'm in university too, and I'm not a idiot. I do know what is required.
Higher gas prices have encouraged people to check out hybrid vehicles in a much greater degree.
starboardlight:
--- Quote from: Giancarlo on July 23, 2006, 09:21:11 pm ---A hybrid engine would last longer because it is built differently (it is not necessarily a combustion engine).
--- End quote ---
the process of turning gasoline into energy is a combustion process. that necessarily makes it a combustion engine.
--- Quote ---I never said that we need protectionism on the petroleum industry. We just need to move gradually, because a demanded sided shock could be disasterous for numerous countries that are in OPEC. It is a gradual process. You're thinking quite simplistically too. I didn't say that technology should advance. Do you even know any of my beliefs? Or are you just going to continue talking down to me like I'm illiterate or a child? I'm in university too, and I'm not a idiot. I do know what is required.
--- End quote ---
and it will be gradual either way. introduction of the electric car is not going all the sudden shut down the petroleum industry. it's not an logical argument against using electric vehicle.
Navigation
[0] Message Index
[#] Next page
[*] Previous page
Go to full version