Brokeback Mountain: Our Community's Common Bond > Brokeback Mountain Open Forum

Would you have lasted 20 years?

(1/9) > >>

mg501:
Every time I watch BBM the one question in the back of my mind is whether I would have hung in for 20 years like Jack did. I'm not saying that Ennis was doing anything wrong. I completely understand what he was struggling with. The scene where he is dry heaving and punching the wall says it all.
I just keep thinking, though, how many times Jack put himself out there for Ennis and how many times Ennis pulled away or just didn't reciprocate. Jack said to Ennis, "Tell ya what, the truth is... sometimes I miss you so much I can hardly stand it." All Ennis did was look down. He said nothing in response. He didn't even lean over and hug Jack. At their reunion at Ennis' apartment the audience can clearly see the intensity of their passion. It must have been enough for Jack to hold on to hope all those years.

ednbarby:
I could have.  Had I not met my husband when I did after "the one that got away" and I broke up and had I just settled for someone I didn't love for money, I absolutely could have and would have.  Thing is, I love my husband, and so after three years of a similar struggle (but on a lesser level, of course, since we're both straight and didn't have the social bullshit keeping us apart - just his need to prove to himself there wasn't a better offer pending somewhere) I was able to give up the ghost.  But not without a lot of heartache.  I'm still not over him completely, nearly 20 years later, and I'd be able to pick his voice out of a crowd in a heartbeat if he was ever within earshot again even though I've neither seen nor spoken to him in about 15 years.

RouxB:
Oh, I hung in for 23 years. Lived my life at the same time but none the less waited for my Ennis for that long. I finally let it go but now with the movie always on my mind, and an emotional voice mail message from him that someone erased before I heard it, I find myself calling again. Oh no! Luckily he never picks up his phone and I never leave a message  ::)

moremojo:
I think I could have hung on if I had been in love as much as Jack obviously was. This kind of soul-searing, life-changing love doesn't come around too often in the course of our time here on earth, and is extremely precious when found. It might be necessary to let go at some point, for some reason, but that decision would not be one to be taken lightly.

In fact, I don't know that I'll ever be able to let Ennis and Jack go. I have fallen hard for these two beautiful characters, and I may be looking at a lifetime colored by my complex feelings regarding them. Amazing, isn't it, that a story and film can do that to a person?

Scott

ednbarby:

--- Quote from: moremojo on April 12, 2006, 04:07:46 pm ---In fact, I don't know that I'll ever be able to let Ennis and Jack go. I have fallen hard for these two beautiful characters, and I may be looking at a lifetime colored by my complex feelings regarding them. Amazing, isn't it, that a story and film can do that to a person?

--- End quote ---

I'm with you, Scott.  I'm fairly certain I'll never get over these two.  Only difference is that in their case, I don't want to.

Navigation

[0] Message Index

[#] Next page