Brokeback Mountain: Our Community's Common Bond > Brokeback Mountain Open Forum

Like I, you want a Brokeback Mountain II, yes a second film??

<< < (13/16) > >>

Artiste:
Thanks!!

I do feel that if Jack had not died, I would gladly see the film much more often, as it scares me and hurts me too much as it is now!!

Plus, I do feel that this film is now for mainly straights!! It is maybe or maybe not a gay story... yet!

That are two more reasons for added BM stories... other film about it or similar films are needed. Hopefully, the next one or ones will be positive and pro-gay without such a violent end... as in BM!!
The violence is too strong and too much continued in this BM!!

Find out what Tremblay is hiding about the end of BM if the director would have added a part not included in this one?????????????????????????????????????????????????????????? We must find that?

Hugs!!

brokebackjack:
Oh that's easy artiste.

Jack kissed Randall.

The mechanics at the garage saw it, lured him into a field and tire ironed him to death.

It would have changed the very essence of the short story AND the audience's view of Jack twist.

So I am glad they left it out.

Artiste:
Thanks brokebackjack!

Even if that (as you say) had been added to the present BM film, that would have not changed the ending, it seems to me! We know that Jack was killed by anti-gays! So why do you say would have changed?

I still insist that a 2nd BM should be done! Are you sure that was what Tremblay meant about: Jack kissing Randall??

Hugs!

brokebackjack:
Artiste that would have changed EVERYTHING.

And it is by no means certain jack was killed by tire iron. Even in nthe book that is never established. It was intentionally left that way by the author: murder or accident? YOU decide. We all decide

Artiste:
Thanks brokenbackjack!

I can NOT see how that would have changed anything!

Nor ONE thing?

Please describe... details needed!!

Hugs!!

Navigation

[0] Message Index

[#] Next page

[*] Previous page