Yikes, if I had to pick solely on the basis of those photos it would be "Neither." Those pictures don't flatter either of them.
Ask and you shall receive, darlin. Same day at the beach...
Sorry, neither do it for me.
And you don't like Heath Ledger and you think Jake Gyllenhaal's head is out of proportion for his body. So who does it for you, Scott? Roger DeBris?