All the criticism is retarded IMO, but Julie is right, the one that gets me the most is the 'wasn't moved/wasn't convinced' by the acting.
Either you accept the acting and all the rest of it falls into place, but to people who didn't accept the acting, there isn't much you can tell them except to stick to animated movies, because if the tremendous world-wide recognition of great acting didn't reach them, they obviously wouldn't know great acting if it bit them on the @ss.