No you didn't, Jeff. Josh is a given. You'd have to be dead to think otherwise.
I'm guessing the one you wouldn't include is Matthew Fox? Just because I think Naveen Andrews is robo-hot and always have, so I'm guessing it's more of a stretch for you, as well as it's been for me, to think of Fox as the same?
I wouldn't have included him a few months ago, either. But I saw him on The Daily Show a month or two ago, and he was just so damned cute. Very Jake-ish - warm, genuine. Smiles a lot. It's not a killer smile like Jake's or Josh's (Second.Best.Smile.Ever), but his very lovely personality shines through whenever he does it.
Plus, I thought the erotic tension between him and Josh was *brutally* hot during that poker game a couple episodes ago. Fine line between love and hate and all that...