Brokeback Mountain: Our Community's Common Bond > Brokeback Mountain Fan Fiction & Poetry
General Discussion and Recs
moremojo:
--- Quote from: louise van hine on July 26, 2007, 03:03:24 pm ---The belief that we each have our own vision is actually built into the rules of this forum area. We actively discourage writers from touting one story as authentic or authorative over another - because it's ALL fanfic, and no one has the blessed holy vision of Jack and Ennis.
--- End quote ---
Quite so, and I would never wish to unintentionally disparage anyone's efforts in this area. Fanfic was an outgrowth, to a large extent anyway, of people's attempts to make sense of the powerful emotions the original story/film engendered in them, and the reading of fanfic often comes out of the same impulse (this was at least true for me). But I honor everyone's desire and effort to create and contribute in their own unique way to this phenomenon we call Brokeback fever.
The only BBM-related story I ever found offensive was one effort (I don't think I would even call it a true fanfic) that was posted by one new user and quickly deleted, as the new member quickly disappeared from the forum as well. I suspect that the user was a troll who didn't escape the moderators' radar for long. Their story, which showed Jack coming to accept and appreciate his situation with Lureen through an unsavory dream of that "sweet life" with Ennis, exhibited a thorough knowledge of the original story and film, but presented the characters in a way that suggested a lack of sympathy for them.
one_of_one:
--- Quote from: Snavel del Snuit on July 26, 2007, 03:14:45 pm ---
Helen,
I am not entirely sure what you mean, because how do you know that the writer believes that his/her work is as close to canon as can be?
--- End quote ---
Because they've said so.
one_of_one:
--- Quote from: Snavel del Snuit on July 26, 2007, 03:14:45 pm ---
Helen,
I am not entirely sure what you mean, because how do you know that the writer believes that his/her work is as close to canon as can be?
Sticking to character in my opinion is not the most important thing when you write a story in which events take a different turn (is that canon, I never did get familiar with the terms), because people can change and things can happen to them that changes the way they look at life. What is more important is if the story you write is compelling and makes people think about how things could've gone differently, sometimes by changing just a single aspect of the story.
I think AU/AU's are so popular right now, not necessarily because they stray so far away from the original characters J&E (because they often do not, Ennis is still often the reticent guy and Jack the open, talkative one), but because we can follow them through the whole falling in love ritual again in a whole different setting, that is what makes it so interesting to read.
Thinking about it now, I have an idea where fanfic is heading: I think there will be more and more extreme AU/AU's (situations totally away from the BBM setting) and then, after a while, writers might start to replace the names Jack and Ennis and write an original story because they have hardly anything to do with BBM anymore.
Mel
--- End quote ---
I think what you're talking about when you mention events taking a different turn is AU. Canon is when a story is written within the events of the original short story or film. There are also canon aspects to AUs and AU!AUs. I agree with what you say about different events changing characterisations - I have always thought that and argued strongly in the early days of fanfic that when you did have such an event taking place that that was the moment when the characters stopped being "in canon" and started to take on different aspects.
I think you're right about the direction AU!AUs are taking. A lot of writers around now seem to have a somewhat tenuous connection to BBM. About what you say regarding Ennis=reticent, Jack=talkative. I know there's more to it than that, but also there is more to Jack and Ennis than just one character trait.
For me I've usually taken one or two characteristics and expanded on them whilst damping down others but I think once you do that you are not writing about Jack and Ennis any more, you are writing about two men who you've named J and E because that is the fandom in which the stories are being written.
:)
one_of_one:
--- Quote from: louise van hine on July 26, 2007, 03:03:24 pm ---The belief that we each have our own vision is actually built into the rules of this forum area. We actively discourage writers from touting one story as authentic or authorative over another - because it's ALL fanfic, and no one has the blessed holy vision of Jack and Ennis.
--- End quote ---
Well said.
Scott6373:
The one thing I could never quite wrap my brain around were those folks who blatantly said: "I don't read dead Jack stories". They were rather a rabid bunch abuot the subject. Whenever I heard that, my skin crawled, he was dead...so, did you see the movie? Read the book? Guess AP had no justification in killing the poor guy off, let's annihalate her, and make her life miserable.
Navigation
[0] Message Index
[#] Next page
[*] Previous page
Go to full version