Our BetterMost Community > Chez Tremblay
Annie Proulx's still pissed...
louisev:
--- Quote from: Jeff Wrangler on March 06, 2010, 11:44:45 am ---Tell you what, in view of some of the "slashier" stuff I've seen, I can't say as I blame her. :-\ But let be, let be. ...
--- End quote ---
Yeah but as I said above, the right of parody and commentary is a protection afforded under the US First amendment. And yes, parodies can be pretty repugnant. I've had my work "parodied"- as well as my person, except that, as a private individual, impugning my reputation is a violation of my constitutional right to privacy. Not so my stories, though. Free speech, it's a wonderful thing, except when someone uses their free speech to mock yours. Then it's a constitutionally protected PAIN IN THE ASS.
Jeff Wrangler:
--- Quote from: louisev on March 06, 2010, 04:13:53 pm ---Yeah but as I said above, the right of parody and commentary is a protection afforded under the US First amendment. And yes, parodies can be pretty repugnant. I've had my work "parodied"- as well as my person, except that, as a private individual, impugning my reputation is a violation of my constitutional right to privacy. Not so my stories, though. Free speech, it's a wonderful thing, except when someone uses their free speech to mock yours. Then it's a constitutionally protected PAIN IN THE ASS.
--- End quote ---
I didn't mean to excuse her (over)reaction, only to comment that in view of some of the stuff I've seen "out there," both in terms of content and writing, I can understand it if she were repulsed by it, and I sympathize with that response.
Front-Ranger:
I've seen the personal replies to letters gay men have sent AP and they are very thoughtful, considerate, and compassionate. And these are handwritten letters. There are also men that she stays in contact with and encourages. In fact, she seems to me to be the embodiment of Mrs. Twist, understanding, perceptive, intuitive, long-suffering and patient. She harbors a deep anger, though, a righteous indignation, and a strong sense of justice and judgment.
Another reason that I believe AP is protective of her intellectual property is that she must be protecting the real life Ennis and Jack, and sees these fanfic publications as slanders against them and against the spirit of the real life people. AP has been married several times, and has three sons, and wrote for male oriented publications for many years, so I'm sure there is a real life Ennis somewhere.
Marina:
I came across this amazing article about one of Annie Proulx's recent writing projects, Red Desert. This is why I love her - not only did she give us the beautiful short story of Brokeback Mountain, but now this:
http://www.hcn.org/issues/41.6/the-desert-that-breaks-annieproulxs-heart-wyoming/article_view?b_start:int=1&-C=
I haven't seen this book out yet?
I did happen to pick up Fine Just The Way It Is also. :)
Front-Ranger:
Annie has been working on this book since at least 2007. Its publication was delayed. I'm excited to see it is finally out. It was meant to be a photography book and she was writing the preface, but her role may have been expanded since she wrote a great deal more than could be included. I went to a talk she gave in early 2007 where she read excerpts that she said could not be included for lack of space. They were fascinating.
Navigation
[0] Message Index
[*] Previous page
Go to full version