Our BetterMost Community > The Polling Place
Who has seen these controversial moments?
Daniel:
I have modified my votes also. After seeing the film the last time, I did indeed hear Ennis whisper "Oh Jack" as he held the shirts up near his mouth. I also heard a ragged breath which seemed to be saying "I love you." He took that deep breath then released it and he seemed to be sighing "I love you." but its not 100% clear, and not clearly enunciated really.
Now as to TS1, as I understand it, Jack grabs Ennis's hand during their lovemaking, places it on his... erection is the term we're using here? and then at the very end of the scene looks as though he is going to kiss Ennis's hand. We watched that scene in slow motion, a few times, just to make sure.
-Daniel.
Brown Eyes:
Is it OK to bump a poll?
Anyway,
Bump!
souxi:
--- Quote from: dly64 on August 20, 2006, 01:09:44 pm ---I heard the "f**k me" ... I swear! ;) ;D It is subtle, but it's there (IMO). I don't know ... I can easily imagine Jack saying that ... especially since he seemed to be wanting to have the "opportunity" (i.e. for Ennis to "f**k" him ... you know what I mean?) for quite awile! ;D
--- End quote ---
Yep I heard that too. You know what I did? I listened to the sound through my headphones. I heard him say "f**k me" I heard him say "I,m sorry" I heard Ennis say "Jack" and "I love you" in the closet. You really have to listen but I DID hear it. Tell you what else. With headphones on, the morning after TS1, I actually heard the birds singing and the water running in the stream and I didnt hear that without headphones.
ifyoucantfixit:
--- Quote from: nakymaton on August 01, 2006, 09:57:48 pm ---I did actually hear "c'mere" in the reunion scene (long before I heard anyone discussing it). The rest, though, I don't think are really there. (Though Jack and Ennis are close to holding hands in TS1... I'm just not sure I would call it "hand-holding" exactly.)
But thanks for letting me be a grump! :-*
--- End quote ---
i swear i hear on that ive never heard anyone else tell about before, and i dont know if its truly there, its just something that i feel hear, kind of like the way you discern something someone says after you know part of it and then put it together in your head. after the reunion, and ennis breaks away from jack and nuzzles him and starts to walk away, he say what i swear is "wait up" and starts to walk up to the stairs...always wonder if anyone else noticed that....
Cameron:
I haven't seen this thread before, what a great one.
I just voted, but only for three of them, the two hand holdings in TS 1 and Jack saying "I'm sorry".
I have read about some of these in other places, but I never did hear them aside from 'I'm sorry'.
These things haven't been discussed in a long long time, I thought I would bump this too.
Navigation
[0] Message Index
[#] Next page
[*] Previous page
Go to full version