Brokeback Mountain: Our Community's Common Bond > Brokeback Mountain Open Forum

What's up with Jenny?

<< < (3/3)

Jeff Wrangler:
Lots of good thoughts here, but let's not discount Alma's appeal that it would be good for their daughters.

I know some folks feel Ennis uses his daughters as an excuse, but I think he does love his little girls and probably is susceptible to the argument that it would be good for them to be closer to other kids to play with (though I note that we only see them playing with each other--on that swing set--though let's also note that Ennis and Alma do set up a swing set for the girls), and not be raised, as he was, on some lonely old ranch.

Mikaela:

--- Quote ---I know some folks feel Ennis uses his daughters as an excuse, but I think he does love his little girls
--- End quote ---

Sure - that's always been my opinion too, that I've now and then argued at length.... Well, about movie Ennis, that is - since the film does make a particular point IMO of presenting both him and Jack throughout as better and more caring fathers than their short story counterparts. And Ennis does talk of taking the girls to town to get them an icecream. So I'm sure you're right the point of what's best for their daughters is also part of the equation of him eventually agreeing to move.

Marge_Innavera:

--- Quote from: Jeff Wrangler on October 23, 2006, 06:08:38 pm ---I know some folks feel Ennis uses his daughters as an excuse, but I think he does love his little girls and probably is susceptible to the argument that it would be good for them to be closer to other kids to play with (though I note that we only see them playing with each other--on that swing set--though let's also note that Ennis and Alma do set up a swing set for the girls), and not be raised, as he was, on some lonely old ranch.

--- End quote ---

There's also the scene where he comes home from work and immediately goes in to tend to the two very young children, both of them crying. And the "cain't we move" bedroom scene starts with references clearly indicating that he's the one who puts both of them to bed. Rather unusual for a husband in the mid-1960s.

One thing about the scene with the toddler Alma Junior and infant Jenny that I didn't catch until the third or fourth viewing is that although Ennis seems tired, this is a domestic scene where he looks involved and not particularly unhappy.

Front-Ranger:
Speaking of two children swinging on a swingset (as we were just doing!) here's a photo of my two kids (love em to pieces) swinging:

Navigation

[0] Message Index

[*] Previous page