Our BetterMost Community > The Polling Place
Would Jack have quit Ennis?
Ellemeno:
I think it would have kept going basically the same - rare meetups that punctuated otherwise excruciating alone loneliness for Ennis, and Mexico/Randall-type loneliness for Jack.
Artiste:
Merci Elle !
That might be... as you say !
May I disagree ?
Au revoir,
hugs!
Brokeback_Dev:
I'm not so optomistic that I think Ennis would change or come around someday. But for sure I dont think Jack could ever quit Ennis. The relationship would go on like it had for 20 years, but with fewer and fewer meetings. Also, there is the off chance that Randall and Jack would have moved up to Lightning Flat and whip the old ranch into shape as OMT mentioned to Ennis when Ennis went up to get Jack's ashes. :'(
Either way Jack didnt know how to quit Ennis.
Artiste:
Merci brokeback dev !
You say: I'm not so optomistic that I think Ennis would change or come around someday. But for sure I dont think Jack could ever quit Ennis. The relationship would go on like it had for 20 years, but with fewer and fewer meetings. Also, there is the off chance that Randall and Jack would have moved up to Lightning Flat and whip the old ranch into shape as OMT mentioned to Ennis when Ennis went up to get Jack's ashes.
Either way Jack didnt know how to quit Ennis.
.......
And may I say or hope:
1- That Ennis was changing and did come around, since he went to see Jack's parents, etc.;
2- Jack would never quit Ennis, and Ennis too would and did not let go of Jack as we see that he hugs that shirt in his trailer as the end of the movie;
3- Since the relationship went on for 20 years, I think that more and more meetings would have occured, yes since the bond and understand were enriching at each meeting;
4- and, to me, Randall did not and would not have been accepted by Jack... on the long run !
Food for thought ?
Au revoir,
hugs!
souxi:
My own personal opinion is, that they would have met up in November as planned, and Jack would have broken things off with Ennis. Ennis would have started drinking heavily and gradually made himself ill. I think it would have taken Jack leaving him to make him realise what they had, and that he DID love him and I think he,d have packed up, moved out and followed Jack to Texas and tried to make a go of things. As happend in Somebody New. That is exactly how I think things would have worked out, IMO.
Navigation
[0] Message Index
[#] Next page
[*] Previous page
Go to full version