Our BetterMost Community > The Polling Place
Would Jack have quit Ennis?
Monika:
Quit him? No way.
Jack does after all say "I wish I knew how to..." implicating that he doesn´t know how to do that
I think Ennis might have done some progress. As Vermont sunset pointed out to me during the trip to Wyoming Ennis statement to Jack during the "I did once" argumen "I can´t stand to lose anymore, Jack". And if he can´t stand it - he has to fix it, right? And the first step towards that could be him breaking up with Cassie.
But if it had gone so far as them moving in together....don´t know. But progress. I think yes.
But thing´s for certain - Jack would never quit Ennis. To me that just rings very false to the characters and the story. To me BBM is a story about to men who dont want to love each other - but who still (love being a force of nature and all that) and have to pay the prise for that love
Artiste:
Merci brokeback dev !
You say that Ennis thinks about Jack:
Why did you go off and get killed.
........
Dev: may I ask, if therefore, Ennis wanted to be protective of Jack ?
I think so... even if his dad had shown him a tortured body of a gay man ! Do you ?
Au revoir,
hugs!
Artiste:
Merci buffymon !
Your saying about Ennis' action: And the first step towards that could be him breaking up with Cassie.
...
Buffymon: that surprises me, as if Ennis had a sexual relationship with Cassie, because I do not think that he did ! Do you ?
Au revoir,
hugs!
Artiste:
Merci souxi !
You say that Jack: ... would have met up (Ennis) in November as planned, and Jack would have broken things off with Ennis. Ennis would have started drinking heavily and gradually made himself ill.
..............
Souxi, you think really that Jack would have broke off his relationship with Ennis in the following November ?
Why ?
Au revoir,
hugs!
Monika:
--- Quote from: Artiste on June 12, 2008, 06:25:12 pm ---Merci buffymon !
Your saying about Ennis' action: And the first step towards that could be him breaking up with Cassie.
...
Buffymon: that surprises me, as if Ennis had a sexual relationship with Cassie, because I do not think that he did ! Do you ?
Au revoir,
hugs!
--- End quote ---
No I don´t think he did either, but there was clearly a bond between them and they must have been seing each other to some extent - just think of how how heartbroken Cassie gets and her line "Girls don´t fall in love with fun". If she has had time to fall in love, I think they must have been out a few times
Navigation
[0] Message Index
[#] Next page
[*] Previous page
Go to full version