Brokeback Mountain: Our Community's Common Bond > Brokeback Mountain Open Forum
Is Jack still alive?
brokeplex:
--- Quote from: Artiste on January 16, 2008, 03:28:16 pm ---Is Jack still alive?
Is this a possibility? I think so... in more than one way or proof.
Hugs!
--- End quote ---
why would you ask this question? do you have trouble accepting his death, I know it was very hard for me. perhaps that is a useful topic for this thread:
Why is Jacks death so hard for us to accept, in spite of the overwhelming evidence in the ss and film that he died?
Artiste:
Thanks brokeplex, thanks brokenbackjack, thanks moremojo!!
May I answer all of you!!
Of course, like you say brokeplex, I had and have still trouble accepting Jack's death... like my W. (lover was murdered too I figure). Maybe these hard to comprehend things (murder, death, etc.) take time... what (be sad about??)??
Anyway, I do believe more and more that Jack is still alive, in the BM movie. There are some possible clues to that.
I figure that I have found some clues. Help me find others guys (and girls)... please.
Yes, brokenbackjack, I think there are clues in the BM movie that Jack is still alive like Ennis is at he end of the movie!
Moremojo, can you re-find that story you mention... any proof(s) there given Plus any other(s) such stories?
Hugs!! May all gay in the world be safe!! That can be a clue??
moremojo:
--- Quote from: Artiste on January 18, 2008, 01:50:42 pm ---Moremojo, can you re-find that story you mention... any proof(s) there given Plus any other(s) such stories?
--- End quote ---
The arguments were made by the founder and moderator of the following online discussion group:
http://groups.yahoo.com/group/WildWestHistory_GayMen
This is currently an age-restricted group, so you will need to have a Yahoo account, be logged on, and be sure that you have your settings to approve access to 'Adult' groups in place before you can even access the homepage. You will need to become a registered member of the group to have access to the message archive there, in which the arguments to which I refer can be found (assuming that that post is still there).
Artiste:
Thanks very much moremojo!
Wow, such protection.
Could you seek that, ask permission to copy and use it on Bettermost? Please
Hugs!
brokebackjack:
Well, in the story as written Jack is really dead. Really, Most Sincerely dead. As dead as if a house had fallen on his head or he had melted Artiste.
Jack's dead.
That was the crux which made Brokeback great. It was concieved of as a Greek tragedy in short story format
Navigation
[0] Message Index
[#] Next page
[*] Previous page
Go to full version