Couldn't agree more. It's all a cover for a life of sackcloth and ashes. Only yesterday I read that anyone who thinks Ennis deserves a second chance at life should go to hell and back (with smiley icons) see page 185.
Smiley icons and a great big FUCK YOU. Charming, huh? Really a good way to stimulate intelligent discourse.
And the Titanic rationale. Let me see if I have this straight. If you want to see/read a story about a movingon!character, watch Titanic, because Rose does move on, get married, have kids. Yes, she may have betrayed her Jack by doing that, but because it is in the story, it happened, it's canon and thus, those of us who have a moving on need should fulfill that need with Titantic.
For Brokeback, no. There is no moving on for Ennis. Never, in any way, shape or form. I-yi-yi...