DOROTHY -- sung by Judy Collins from HARD TIMES FOR LOVERS
Some may say that my YouTube song suggestions are bleak, speaking only of regret and desolation, and are aimed at those whose lives have not turned out as they planned, and those for whom love has not been their frequent friend. Well, I like sad songs.
Think of "Dorothy" as Judy Collins singing not only about Dorothy in Kansas, and about the people I described, but especially about Ennis some years after he loses Jack, and is thinking back to the summer on the mountain, to "the single moment of artless charmed happiness in their separate and difficult lives."
{Living in Kansas, a life alone,
she never married, she's hardly known.
She stares out the window, far away,
looking for another windy day.
Dorothy was a fool to leave;
she could have stayed.
She held it right in her hands, she had it made.
She could have had it all for keeps, she was afraid,
she could have stayed.
It seems like only yesterday,
but 40 years have up and slipped away,
since a lovely, black-haired girl
was taken for her one and only whirl.
Dorothy was a fool to leave.........
Same old bluebirds flying high
over rainbows in the Kansas sky.
Why oh why?
Oh why?
I guess it only serves her right
for trading all that colour for black and white.
All her sorrow, all because
there ain't no way to stay in Kansas when you've been to Oz.
Dorothy was a fool to leave......}
What makes this song so poignant to me is that life teaches that Dorothy could NOT have stayed in Oz, that the summer on BBM was bound to end, and the snow had to come. But do we have to trade all that colour for black and white so quickly? That is a savage reality to have to face.
[youtube=425,350]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uKW38w8gJfE[/youtube]