Our BetterMost Community > Chez Tremblay
Stay Home.
JennyC:
Obviously we all did not read every post clearly. I doubt if we all read every posts. ;)
Again, no one suggested that illegal immigrants should be sent to jail or ship home. There may be some comments made in the heat of argument to let out the frustration of how some illegal immigrants are indeed bad apples (the argument also made the other way on there are bad apples in every group, even citizens), but again if you read through their posts, they did not say the solution is to sent the current illegal immigrants to jail to ship them home.
No offense, but we have enough ideology talks here, no real solutions. I am interested to know what do you think should be a practical, fair, and fiscal responsible solution package. Maybe it’s too heavy a topic ???
opinionista:
--- Quote ---I agree, but why should they? Their needy people fleeing to another country certainly doesn't bother them. They're just 11 million people less to worry about. This is why it is OUR problem and why WE have to initiate the dialogue and solution with these countries.
--- End quote ---
Actually, losing people to emigration can be a big problem to a country. I don't know about big countries like Mexico or China that are over populated. But the likes of Cuba, Ecuador, Argentina and so on actually suffer from the heavy emigration flow. They're losing skilled personnel which could pose a treath to their economic growth and developtment. Spain for instance, had a massive 'brain drain' during the 1930's and 1960's because of Franco's rule. It had an important impact on the country, and some of the consequences of it are still felt today.
Also, emigration boosts underground economies on both sides of the border. Drug traffiking organizations hire immigrant as mules, drug sellers, etc. in exchange of helping them to cross the border. It fuels the creation of other mafia organizations that work for legal companies bringing in illegal immigrant to work for low wages, or sell false passports, visas and other documents that might help them cross the border for exhorbitants amounts of money.
It also gives a county a bad image, and has a negative effects on their diplomatic relationships with other countries.
The list is long. But you have a point though. Saddly, some politicians couldn't care less and won't do anything about it until the whole thing begins to pose threats to their interests.
--- Quote ---Again, no one suggested that illegal immigrants should be sent to jail or ship home.
--- End quote ---
I didn't say anyone here said that. The whole illegal immigration issue that's going on at the moment is about a law that would make them all criminals, isn't it?
--- Quote ---I am interested to know what do you think should be a practical, fair, and fiscal responsible solution package
--- End quote ---
That's a hard question to answer because things aren't that easy and there are a lot of issues to consider when finding a solution to solve one of the world's oldest problem: immigration. It's complicated problem that require complicated solutions as well, because there are too many interests involved. Do you have the right solution? I think not.
There are several things to consider. For example: US corporations.They contribute a big deal to illegal immigration by lobbying members of the Congress and paying for their campaigns in exchange for international agreements between the US and some third world countries that are beneficial for them but not to those countries' citizens. Exxon Mobile and other companies alike, had control over Venezuela's oil resources for a while until Chavez came in and put a stop to that. They were getting richer and richer while venezuelans were getting poorer and poorer, so common folks like you and me, had no choice but to leave the country. Mexico have similar problems.
I'm not saying US is the only and one responsible for those countries poverty, because we have to take into account the corruption and acts of greed by some third world countries lawmakers and politicians, but it does contribute a lot to their poverty and to illegal immigration.
JennyC:
opinionista,
--- Quote ---The whole illegal immigration issue that's going on at the moment is about a law that would make them all criminals, isn't it?
--- End quote ---
I assume this refer to both the current illegal immigrants in the US as well as any future ones. I think both the house and the senate got the message now. Discussions like this and the protests through out the country in recent weeks delivered that message.
For the existing illegal immigrants/undocumented workers, some program should be set up to provide them a road map to help them legalize their status here. Again, this is not amnesty, they should provide that they are contributing and law biding (not including entering the county illegally) members of the society. And they should not get ahead of others who are in the process and come here legally. I have friends in both boats, legally, illegally (some of them have over stayed their visa). When funding and staffing are limited, some one has to give and become the collateral damage. I am afraid that this will inevitably impact those who decide to play by the rule. If I look the big picture, I hope that by everyone making some concession and enduring some suffering, the whole situation can be greatly improved.
Being realistic on the immigration issue, I think the enforcement aspect of immigration control is still necessary to if not stop, at least contain this vicious circle. This include tightening border control and also putting pressure on employer to not hire illegal immigrants to take advantage of their low labor cost. If there is labor shortage in certain section of the US economy, like agriculture for example, or immigrants help to boom economy, then by all means provide them the legal way to get here and remove the road blocks in the process. We all know that we can not live beyond our means, without any kind of enforcement; we are literally live beyond what the economy can support.
If you catch illegal immigrants at the border, then either send them home or see if the any of the current immigration path applies to them. Today, there are asylum, refugee, special immigrants, employer based immigrants (assuming guess worker will be in this category), family sponsored immigration, etc. Oh hi, there is the immigration lottery. According to Department of State, 50,000 immigrants are admitted into US in the past five years. But this does not apply to the following countries: CANADA, CHINA (mainland-born), COLOMBIA, DOMINICAN REPUBLIC, EL SALVADOR, HAITI, INDIA, JAMAICA, MEXICO, PAKISTAN, PHILIPPINES, POLAND, RUSSIA, SOUTH KOREA, UNITED KINGDOM (except Northern Ireland) and its dependent territories, and VIETNAM. Persons born in Hong Kong SAR, Macau SAR and Taiwan are eligible.
I have two friends, one is Brazilian, one from a country that is part of the former Soviet Union (the name does not come to my mind now) got their green card through the lottery system.
Del,
I agree with star's analysis on declining immigrants from Indian and China. Have to get to this one next time.
I have found a very interesting Immigration Studies on Center for Immigration Studies’s website. It’s done by two economists. It’s a short document, but if you find the paper boring, just read the first page. See attached file.
NPR also has a quite comprehensive webpage organizing various topics on Immigration Debate: http://www.npr.org/templates/story/story.php?storyId=5310549&sourceCode=gaw
opinionista:
--- Quote ---Being realistic on the immigration issue, I think the enforcement aspect of immigration control is still necessary to if not stop, at least contain this vicious circle.
--- End quote ---
US has been tightening its border since forever, and it hasn't exactly worked. They always find a way to come in. To competely close a border is like trying to cover the sky with your hands. I'm sorry but that's not realistic. Do you know what Cubans are doing now to enter the states? Instead of taking a so called balsa and go to Miami, they go to Mona, a small Island a few miles off Puerto Rico's coast that falls inside the US border. Once there, they're officially on US territory and cannot be sent back to Cuba.
Moreover, thousands of immigrant from Dominican Republic enter Puerto Rico everyday through sea. Some are caught but the great majority are successful. They stay on the island a few years, manage to pick a Puerto Rican accent and since they look a lot like us, they travel to US mainland posing like Puerto Ricans.
Puerto Rico belongs to the US and Puerto Ricans are american citizens, so all flights from and to mainland are domestic. There can be no passport control at airports because that'll be like asking people from Boston to show their passports before entering New York. Stopping immigrants is next to impossible.
But I don't completely disagree with you. I wrote a post where I said that the best way to deal with the illegal immigrants that are already in the country is to provide them with the tools to become legal resident and law abiding citizens. But that won't eliminate illegal immigration as a national problem. Something else has to be done. A lot of these people migrate because they have no other choice, if they could stay where they belong they would.
delalluvia:
--- Quote from: JennyC on May 07, 2006, 01:41:16 pm ---Del,
I agree with star's analysis on declining immigrants from Indian and China. Have to get to this one next time.
I have found a very interesting Immigration Studies on Center for Immigration Studies’s website. It’s done by two economists. It’s a short document, but if you find the paper boring, just read the first page. See attached file.
NPR also has a quite comprehensive webpage organizing various topics on Immigration Debate: http://www.npr.org/templates/story/story.php?storyId=5310549&sourceCode=gaw
--- End quote ---
Thanks for the link and the attached file. Interesting reading. The Immigration Study is pretty much what I've heard from others, wages and quality of living will go up for the immigrants, but wages will be cut and quality of living go down for the natives.
Navigation
[0] Message Index
[#] Next page
[*] Previous page
Go to full version