I voted 'Somewhat', in large part because I'm just not a Brad Pitt fan (no offence to him as a person or as an actor). Gale Harold is cute, but the character he plays on "Queer as Folk" is frankly kind of a jerk (not that that should have any bearing on these results). The name/face that was new to me, and which really piqued my curiosity, was that of Robert Gant (very handsome indeed).
As for those left out...hmmmm...well, I've always been fond of David Schwimmer. Robert Carlyle is also very appealing in a kind of "disreputable" way. Russell Crowe, though not particularly admirable as a human being, exudes raw animal allure that can't be denied. And I was recently reminded how extremely attractive Bruce McGill was/is--I could fall for someone like his D-Day very easily.