Hey
Jess - I don't think I know the song "What Made America Famous" - I'll go see if I can find it somewhere - the last stanza seems awfully familiar.
Well Lynne, you know how much I love you, but I am afraid I have to disagree with this. It is wonderful and
fine in idea, but the fact is the carrying out of the program hits a brick wall in most, cases.
These people tend to have been searching for a scapegoat for their own problems. They have some
major issue or another,,,in this case its the death of the brother... They cant rationally blame themself. They may blame God, and themself as I did. Or they can find some other outliet for that hate. In this case he has
decided it is the fault of the cloying homosexuals that ensnared his poor brother.
I happen to know intimately someone like this. all they do when you try to teach them a different thought. Is to get angry and combative. in other words the mind is made up, don't try to confuse them with facts.
You can and may well change people that are middle of the road minded but, i dont think you are going to get very far with folks like this.. JMO
I wish I had your optimism
Janice, we can disagree - if we didn't, one of us would be redundant.
I freely admit to seeing glasses as half-full and rose-colored. I don't know that I'd wish it on you because evidently it also makes me naive. I used to think it was a good plan to trust people until they give you a reason not to; now I've seen that that can be a truly dangerous proposition.
I know 'these people' too. They were my relatives and neighbors growing up - with the notable exception of Grandma Mamie, who
is was what I think I can now call a "Mrs. Twist Christian" and be understood. If it weren't for her, I am pretty sure I'd be atheist instead of agnostic. Those memories of singing old-timey hymns with her while she pushed me on the swingset or we worked in the garden are just too precious.
You are right that the usual reaction to new ideas is frequently anger and resistance. (I like 'Don't try to confuse them with facts' - that's a good one
. ) But still, if you're gracious and civil about it, there's a slight chance that your point of view will be remembered - perhaps the next time someone else espouses it - like drops of rain making a dent in a rock. It's worth a shot, IMO, largely because simply letting it pass is tantamount to endorsement - and after
Brokeback Mountain, I try very very hard to no longer let homophobia pass without comment.