Is there a "John Luck... Pickard" here?
6% Benjamin_Sisko, 30% Kathryn_Janeway, 45% Jean-Luc_Picard, 5% Johnathan_Archer, 8% William_Adama and 19% James_T_Kirk!
The fans of Star Trek with more than half a brain will always vote this guy as the better of the two. In the classic "Kirk vs Picard" argument, Picard should always win because he was simply the better man. The only thing Kirk could do was fight. Picard could fight, negotiate, verbally castrate, be assimilated and not have it dominate his character afterwards, and all this with such eloquence and grace. One of the more ironic characters, in that he was French with a British accent, he would speak and people would shut up and listen. He was never one to be fooled, either, and is probably the only captain here who could competently challenge Data to a philosphical debate.