The mysterious "I love you" and other nearly indiscernible moments

[jpwagoneer1964]

Everyone hear "Give them hell" When Ennis starts to get up to go to the sheep before FNIT? I do, but not until it was pointed out to me.

[Rutella]

Everyone hear "Give them hell" When Ennis starts to get up to go to the sheep before FNIT? I do, but not until it was pointed out to me.

goddamn another reason to watch BBM again tonight to see if I can hear that....What a hard life I have 

[dly64]

Everyone hear "Give them hell" When Ennis starts to get up to go to the sheep before FNIT? I do, but not until it was pointed out to me.

Are you saying Ennis says that? Why? (Here I go again being skeptical. Prove me wrong!) At what moment would he actually say that? After he says, “It’s too late to go up to them sheep”?

[jpwagoneer1964]

Are you saying Ennis says that? Why? (Here I go again being skeptical. Prove me wrong!) At what moment would he actually say that? After he says, “It’s too late to go up to them sheep”?

Sorry it's Jack that says it to Ennis. Right after Ennis says "I'll guess I go up to the sheep now".

[dly64]

Sorry it's Jack that says it to Ennis. Right after Ennis says "I'll guess I go up to the sheep now".

That makes more sense. I'll have to watch and see if I hear it!

[Ellemeno]

That makes more sense. I'll have to watch and see if I hear it!

You can see it in the subtitles.  I know they aren't infallible, but in this case, it seems right.

[dly64]

You can see it in the subtitles.  I know they aren't infallible, but in this case, it seems right.

I just checked it out and you are right! What a crack up!

[iluvchocolate]

Well both my husband (horo35) and I watched that scene and well we both don't agree.  I hear "i love you" and I don't think he heard anything.  I turned closed captions on to see if it would pick it up... of course it didn't.  Now I am sure he's saying I love you!!

[serious crayons]

The "I love you" is right here. Ennis (Heath) is actually saying it in this still. The second he gets the words out scene exits to Mrs Twist with coffee cup in kitchen.

Mark, I agree -- that is the moment.

Your photo makes me think of something else: how many times in key scenes we see Ennis grasping a handful of Jack's clothing. Here, the end of the lake scene, the dozy embrace.

[dly64]

Mark, I agree -- that is the moment.

Your photo makes me think of something else: how many times in key scenes we see Ennis grasping a handful of Jack's clothing. Here, the end of the lake scene, the dozy embrace.

... the reunion scene, TS1, etc. Great observation!