The mysterious "I love you" and other nearly indiscernible moments

[bbm_stitchbuffyfan]

I still have to listen for this supposed "I love you."

[dly64]

I still have to listen for this supposed "I love you."

I was the biggest disbeliever. Read an earlier post and you will see where you can find it. I thought they were crazy! I was wrong. It's there!

[mvansand76]

I love that nonchalant response, mvansand76. You: "Did you hear anything?" Him: "No. ... Well, nothing except him saying 'I love you' when he holds the shirts up to his face.'" Little does he know the intense controversy he's talking about!

 

Yeah, he's very nonchalant in that way! 
I thought it was a very good test!

[jpwagoneer1964]

Finally heard "f..k me" in the first tent scene. Just once so far.

[Daphne7661]

Ohhh, why can't I hear it?  I can hear everything else, but not that.   

I DO hear one of them say "F___", but it sounds like Ennis....

At what point do we hear Jack say "F____ me"?

[jpwagoneer1964]

Ohhh, why can't I hear it?  I can hear everything else, but not that.   

I DO hear one of them say "F___", but it sounds like Ennis....

At what point do we hear Jack say "F____ me"?

Right after Ennis enters him. Not very clear and in the middle of grunts but I did hear it, you might have to try a few times.

[Daphne7661]

OK, jp, I guess I'll have to watch again..   

I'll listen for it at that point.

Thanks!!!

 

[dly64]

Right after Ennis enters him. Not very clear and in the middle of grunts but I did hear it, you might have to try a few times.

Okay ... something new I have to check out! I'll listen and see if I can hear it. I have been unable to so far. Too bad Jack doesn't say .... "Gun's goin' off ..." like he did in the book! YEEHAW! 

[serious crayons]

Hmm! Good one, goadra! I've always heard it as kind of, "mmmeeehhh, meeehhh, mmmmeehhh" or something like that (sorry, it's been a few weeks since I saw it). But given all we've talked about here, I like the possibility that he's actually saying words.

[Brown Eyes]

Anyone have any idea what (if anything) Ennis says as he punches the wall?

Well, I do think a lot of it is inarticulate.  But, I hear him say something like "god damn" in the middle of everything.  It sounds mostly like a mixture of sobbing and moaning.