I have been reading over there since the thread started, but don't post either because of the envirnment there. I think it is great that forums do break off to follow stories and authors that they like and enjoy--why not. Only makes sense to me.
I find it kind of funny---I don't post comments to Bailey's stories, because the Ennis in most of those stories is as far removed from the Ennis I know from Annie's BBM story, as Bailey claims Louise's Ennis is removed, and I always hear Thumper's Mother (and mine) in the back of my head--If you can't say something nice, don't say NOTHING at all. So I don't, cause saying I can't identify with that Ennis would serve no purpose, since it is a matter of personal perspection, Bailey has their own as I have mine.
When I like something, I say so like in Human Interest, Two Crows Joy and Laramie as well as many others, and sometimes when something doesn't work for me, I say so too, and why it won't work for me, like in Mainewriter's getting Ennis pierced---I told her why it didn't, and don't comment on it anymore, cause it is her story, I am strictly a spectator and have learned to go with the flow.
And when there is something new that I do like, I comment again.
I have had an author or two tell me, when I said something didn't work for me, but that I liked the premise of the story anyway, that I should maybe look for other fics to read. So I kept reading, but quit commenting. Best thing to do is simply ignore the whole mess---those who love it will still love it even if every aspect isn't the way they want it---and those who don't, aren't ever going to-so it is simply wasted effort to try to justify or placate them-not worth the effort. Just my own opinion, I read a lot of it, but I don't write down my fanfic, I just do a day dream inside my head.
It doesn't just happen with BBM stories either---you find it every where---on every subject.
I have been reading four or five different types of fanfics, and there are pros and cons about every one of them at some point in time.